Opinion Setting the record straight on 5 top MDM issues

Published
  • April 26 2017, 6:45am EDT

As the so-called ‘godfather of the MDM market,’ and a regular sanguine commentator on the market’s solutions, my analyst career has often had to “call out” the hypsters on numerous occasions.

As my IT industry friends tell me, “Zornes does not fear blowback from the vendors... he calls out ‘hype’ as he knows it when he sees it.” Audiences at my MDM & Data Governance Summits (12 years and still growing) know how true it is when I say “Vendors, please check your weapons at the door” when they attend my Field Report sessions that review the pros and cons of the Top 20 solutions in MDM (RDM, Data Governance, etc.).

With that perspective in mind, let me separate the facts from the alternative facts on five trends in MDM.

Multi-domain remains dogma not practice

Our analyst friends at Gartner have now (after 10-plus years) bought into the marketing mantra the notion of “multi-domain MDM” (the ability to support “party” and “thing” via the same MDM product family). The meaning there is yet another Magic Quadrant that purports to rank MDM platforms on the basis of their “multi-domain” capabilities.

Note that I say “family” not “software stack” as the mega vendors are still selling separate software (not integrated) stacks for customer and product.

Moreover, in one of Gartner’s recent reports they state “The percentage of these thousands of interactions that expressed some level of requirement for multiple master data domains quadrupled from 3.0% to 14.0% overall” ... That data point does *not* compel one to believe that multi-domain MDM is required by anything near a majority of the market. To the contrary, enterprises continue to acquire MDM on the basis of solving specific business problems tactically and (often) end up with more than one brand even of MDM solution to solve multiple business initiatives

So settle down, MDM evaluators and stop relying upon overly simplistic eye candy graphs to justify your short lists (!). Multi-domain MDM is marketing dogma, not practice!

Proactive data governance integration with MDM platforms remains conceptual

Despite all the massive marketing with vendors attempting to brainwash the masses that they have integrated/proactive connectivity between (MDM hub “A”) and (Data Governance tool “B”), the facts remain that MuleSoft + coding does *not* constitute “out of the box integration.”

“Death by a thousand whitepapers/webcasts” cannot alone compel us to believe that such integration exists, despite all the noise.

Yes, the MDM vendors are much more serious than ever about acquiring (or developing) proactive/integrated Data Governance capabilities, yet the roadmap for integration extends pretty far out into the future for such vital capabilities.

It is clear that, given the importance of MDM’s contribution to business value, acceleration, velocity and necessity for digital transformation (among many of its justifications), MDM remains co-dependent upon data governance processes. And organizations are numb to the fact that they still must custom code SharePoint or other capabilities to deliver the “final (integration) mile” between MDM and Data Governance ... via consultancy engagements typically.

Graph database is conceptually threatening MDM due to its ability to simplify complexity

But in practice, the majority of graph-specific implementations either (a) are unable to transact for high volume scalability in operational mode or (b) are primarily being used as adjuncts to operational mode/transactional MDM hubs to cross-walk/analyze across domains.

Additionally, graph technology also provides ease of metadata management, not just MDM, with canonical models for data integration. However, there is a dearth of data models for graph (unlike IBM, Informatica, Oracle and SAP MDM solutions). If you are the do-it-yourself type, then you can build a sophisticated analytics capability to layer on top of existing data sources – including legacy or current MDM hubs.

To further support this notion, check out what IBM, Informatica and Oracle have publicly announced about their Graph capabilities for MDM – not a replacement technology but an adjunct to existing MDM capabilities.

Microsoft is *not* A “no show” to the MDM party

Rather, Microsoft remains “late to the event” in terms of functionality and “still can’t dance” when it comes to operational scalability.

Look to Microsoft to leverage Azure in native ways that bring economic viability to new MDM use cases and architectures. However, be prepared to custom code your way through the lack of key MDM capabilities by Microsoft.

MDM as managed service = Hot

Cloud momentum for MDM hosting is increasing albeit from the business side, not the IT side. Just as business users increasingly gave up on IT to deliver modest CRM in a timely, cost effective fashion (remember all the Siebel CRM debacles), so too are marketing and sales teams especially looking to improve the quality of their customer data... and pay for it as a “service” rather than as a complex, long-time-to-value capital expenditure that IT manages.

To that end, the consultancies (large and small) have found “cloud” (MDM as a hosted service, data quality as a service) now to be a key door opener and enable them to sell recurring revenue programs (to replace the large-scale IT-based projects they have been addicted to revenue-wise).

This is causing the large-scale consultancies to also revamp their revenue/pricing models in a sea change manner much like other IT solutions providers (software, data centers, networking hardware, etc.).

In short, 2017-18 will continue to provide MDM market watchers with lots of entertainment.

(Editor’s note: The 12th annual MDM Summit will be held in San Francisco July 12-14, 2017).

Register or login for access to this item and much more

All Information Management content is archived after seven days.

Community members receive:
  • All recent and archived articles
  • Conference offers and updates
  • A full menu of enewsletter options
  • Web seminars, white papers, ebooks

Don't have an account? Register for Free Unlimited Access

Aaron Zornes

Aaron Zornes

Aaron Zornes is chief research officer of The MDM Institute and conference chairman for the MDM & Data Governance Summit series.