Microsoft’s GitHub deal triggers software coders’ trust issues
(Bloomberg) -- The software-development world was rocked on Monday when Microsoft Corp. said it’s acquiring GitHub Inc., a popular online platform for sharing and collaborating on code. While some programmers think the news is terrific, others say it’s terrifying.
Their fear comes from a very real historical clash between open-source coders, who freely post and share their work, and Microsoft, which became one of the world’s largest companies by selling proprietary software and fiercely protecting its technology. In 2001, a Windows executive called open source “an intellectual-property destroyer,” and hinted that it went against “the American Way” of doing business. Former Chief Executive Officer Steve Ballmer called it a “cancer.”
The Microsoft of today, which is focused on cloud computing and has forged new partnerships under CEO Satya Nadella, is far different from the open-source-hostile one of years past. But not all software developers have noticed the shift, and not everyone trusts the company that was once a central antagonist to the types of developers who congregate on GitHub.
“Microsoft has a very long history of abusing its position vis-a-vis open source and other companies,” wrote coder Jacques Mattheij in a blog post after Bloomberg News reported the agreement. He also said he deleted his GitHub account. “I’m sure you’ll be able to tell I’m a cranky old guy by looking up the dates to some of these references, but ‘new boss, same as the old boss’ applies as far as I’m concerned. Yes, the new boss is a nicer guy but it’s the same corporate entity.”
Microsoft is buying GitHub for $7.5 billion in stock. In a measure that should reassure some worried GitHub users, the company will remain independent, and plans to support development in various programming languages with a range of tools – and will enable that code to be run on various operating systems, from Microsoft or its rivals’. And many developers who want GitHub to succeed have acknowledged that the 10-year-old startup needed a lifeline. Before the deal was announced, the company had been searching for a new CEO for nine months and had yet to turn a profit.
Still, others have taken to Twitter to express their unease, posting threats to switch from GitHub to rival products as well as jokes and memes protesting the platform’s new corporate master.
“It totally makes sense that people would be skeptical,” said Chris Wanstrath, GitHub co-founder and outgoing CEO, in an interview. “I, a couple of years ago, would never have imagined this deal happening.” Microsoft’s actions in the past few years have shown their commitment to open-source developers, he said.
Other coders were similarly pleased. Guillermo Rauch, a GitHub user and cloud-software startup executive, tweeted that the deal is “one of the best things to happen to Open Source.”
GitHub’s users accepting Microsoft is a “very critical element,” Microsoft’s Nadella said in an interview on Bloomberg TV. “We’ll have to earn the trust,” he said. “Our actions from the recent past should reassure every developer of what Microsoft’s intent is.”
Back in the early 2000s, as open-source software gained popularity, Microsoft was its biggest opponent. The company tried to pry away customers who ran their corporate networks on open-source operating system Linux with tactics ranging from price cuts to fear-mongering over the notion that the software could be vulnerable to patent-infringement suits.
In Ballmer’s later years as CEO, the company began to soften its stance. Ballmer dispatched a key lieutenant to a Linux conference in 2004 to take questions – clad in a flak jacket – and later struck a deal with Oracle Corp. that involved making that company’s version of Linux available through Microsoft’s cloud software.
But it was Nadella who ramped up open-source compatibility and product development at Microsoft. The company’s Azure cloud lets customers host a variety of Linux workloads, and a large percentage of Azure customers do exactly that. Microsoft has open-sourced some of its Visual Studio developer tools’ code through GitHub, and has done the same for some of its cloud services. In April, Microsoft introduced a product for securing systems for connected devices – known as the internet of things -- that runs a homegrown version of Linux rather than Windows.
“Now we are all-in on open source,” Nadella said on Monday.
Plenty of developers aren’t quite ready to trust the software giant. GitHub rival GitLab is trying to capitalize on this uncertainty, tweeting about how many developers are moving their code repositories to its network.
“I think it's a no-brainer that if you start today you should start on GitLab,” said GitLab CEO Sid Sijbrandij. “Not because GitHub is owned by Microsoft but because it's a fundamentally different and better product.” Still, he said competing with Microsoft will be tough.
As for Microsoft, it’s asking concerned coders to give it a chance.
“We ask that developers judge us by our actions -- both our recent actions over the last several years of working with developers, working in open source, and by our actions going forward,” said Nat Friedman, the Microsoft executive who will become CEO of GitHub. “We think the principles we’ve set up of openness, of developer-first and of independence, are the right principles for GitHub to continue to grow and to continue to deserve the trust that developers place in it today,”
--With assistance from Emily Chang