As a kid, I loved listening to Rush and trying to understand where he was coming from, trying to understand his perspective, trying to understand his ideology. The term “culture wars” in U.S. politics is used to define a clash between two different political ideologies – conservatism and liberalism.
Over the past few years, I’ve also started using the term “culture wars” to describe the clash and fragmentation we’ve seen in the BPM market. In the BPM space, the clash has primarily been around dynamic case management, human-centric workflow and straight through processing ideologies.
I’m the first to admit that fragmentation and categorization is not always a bad thing, since it can help software buyers and decision makers better understand which solutions best match their business requirements and desired business outcomes. However, the fragmentation in BPM sometimes overlooks the primary purpose and value proposition of BPM – to help support creating a sustainable business change program.
Whether you’re looking to enter into BPM from a dynamic case management (DCM) perspective, a human workflow perspective, a smart process perspective, or a straight through processing perspective is really only one piece of the puzzle. The other big piece of the puzzle focuses on building out sustainable practices that continue to deliver real business value and transformational benefits over an extended period of time.
Over the last six months, my colleague Derek Miers and I immersed ourselves in evaluating the landscape for BPM suites. A key part of this research focused on how well BPM suites supported building out a sustainable business change program, as opposed to just delivering individual process projects from siloed perspectives. Through our research, we found that the next generation of BPM suites focus on helping change programs:
- Design and deliver the right customer experiences. No longer relegated to the back-office, BPM is beginning to play a critical role in driving customer experience initiatives. These initiatives range from companies looking to overhaul customer service processes to companies seeking to deliver more compelling experiences that incorporate big data analytics and real-time guidance. This shift to focus on experience design is also driven by the need to reinvent legacy and inflexible business processes, enabling them to work more fluidly in mobile and social environments.
- Use business architecture to connect strategy to implementation, ensuring outcomes. Business architects are playing a broader role in driving business change initiatives. In many cases, these architects focus on defining the strategy for transforming end-to-end business processes. Historically, BPM tools offered very little to help these business strategists scope and manage large-scale change projects. This disconnect between strategy and execution keeps BPM suites isolated to the CIO’s office, without a way to have a greater impact on enterprise strategy. The next generation of BPM suites provides a much tighter connection between strategy design and execution.
- Build end-to-end processes that span multiple process patterns. Historically, Forrester has tracked BPM software across three different market segments: document-centric BPM suites, human-centric-BPM suites, and integration-centric BPM suites. However, through market consolidation these three segments are merging into a single BPM suite offering that can cover three different work patterns: dynamic case management (DCM), human workflow, and straight-through processing. Increasingly we see BPM suites moving toward the provision of a single design and development environment that support multiple process patterns and use cases.
So in a very real sense, these three trends are forcing BPM suites to move beyond individual ideological views of business process. Instead of taking pot shots at each other, savvy vendors are focusing on supporting change programs that can deal with internal and external disruption. In short, BPM suites have matured since our 2010 market evaluation and are positioned to have a greater impact across the enterprise, for both business and IT.
This blog originally appeared at Forrester Research.